"We are alternative voices seeking to share the overflow of our hearts with the Christian College Community."

September 24, 2005

Evangelism or Advertising?

Filed under: Blog — Bryan Blakeley @ 11:40 am

I was recently watching one of those late-night televangelist broadcasts, featuring an attractive older man standing in front of what looked to be thousands of people, all desperately waiting on his every word. After a short introduction, he brought out a guest, namely, Jordan S. Rubin, creator of “The Maker’s Diet” (www.makersdiet.com). As Mr. Rubin would go on to explain, there are certain foods that are Biblically mandated for a healthy lifestyle, and others that are specifically forbidden. Things such as shellfish and pork, clearly outlined as off-limits in Leviticus, are only harmful to the body. Other foods like figs, olive oil, and wine are mentioned positively, and are thus beneficial to the body. Now, I have no desire to debate the differences between Israel and the Church, argue the particular relevancy of the Old Covenant within the New, or follow any of the other numerous possible tangents. And to be quite honest, I don’t particularly care if the diet works or not.

What really upsets me is the fact that God is being used to market a product. Christian beliefs about the Bible are being manipulated to sell copies of a diet plan.

It’s not like this is a wholly unknown phenomenon. Who profited from the WWJD phenomenon? I’m willing to bet it wasn’t the local churches. Who makes the popular car attachments shaped like fish? I don’t know, but I’m willing to bet they make out alright. This, however, is something slightly different, and something far worse. In fact, I think this is really insidious. The Maker’s Diet says, in effect, that God has created some food to be eaten, and eaten properly, and it is Christian duty to abide by these rules. If a person truly believes in the Bible, and believes that what the Bible says is true, then he or she should be following The Maker’s Diet. This goes far beyond bumper-sticker faith proclamation. This deals with moral responsibility, with pleasing God, and with interpreting the sacred texts of our tradition. Perhaps the plan works, perhaps is doesn’t. That’s not the point. The point is that Christians are being manipulated and guilt-tripped into buying this book. I, for one, am sickened.

4 Comments »

  1. I thought you really were going to launch into the stuff about how the Old covenant was abolished, but I think you hit the problem on the head even more so. I think you are really on to something there Bryan. You’ve always been a great writer though. Keep it up!

    Comment by Brandon Blakeley — September 25, 2005 @ 11:17 am

  2. wow. Yeah, to further your disgust, a book was written: What Would Jesus Eat?

    I think your right, about the advertising thing. The question is what do we do to counter act that?

    Comment by Ariah Fine — September 25, 2005 @ 6:03 pm

  3. bryan,
    guess what? this is happening in HK too. except it’s not quite as bad as marketing an actual diet plan; it’s more like nutrition-theology. I don’t like the advertising as well. I wonder: how does one create a product whose creation is based on biblical “roots” (decent ones), and market it in a way that doesn’t trivialise the gospel, or turn it into a marketplace, or into a product for someone else’s profit for that matter?

    like, there’s nothing inherently wrong with a WWJD bracelet or a fish or a CD with worship on it. so how do you sell legitimate christian goods in a way that does not turn them into…what they have become?? :P

    Comment by richard wu — September 27, 2005 @ 4:13 am

  4. dude… thats right on…

    i cant imagine what they are gonna do next… make everyone become vegetarians because daniel did it?

    i guess this is the fine line between doing stuff for God, and taking His Name in vain…

    Comment by aaron — October 1, 2005 @ 4:02 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Powered by WordPress

Visits: